For this reason, siskins wants to build a simulated world to gather the same information but in a less obtrusive fashion. Unlike most artifical intelligence films, these robots are bound by 3 simple laws that should keep mankind in complete control. I will not point out the plot differences to you because it will take way too long. Film post on divergent, im going to break down the differences as i see them between the film and book versions of the maze runner. Difference between movies and books difference between. Robot historian fred barton was commissioned to restore robby to his original 1956 state while the robot was still on display at. Nov 16, 2014 blog 8 film analysis of i,robot chicago the year 2025, robots are manufactured to serve humans, in a world where they live simultaneously together.
Book vs movie replay i, robot 15th anniversary special movie isaac asimov classic short stories vs will smith blockbuster. Book vs movie i, robot replay 15th anniversary special ep. In little lost robot the missing robot operated under a modified first law. With this chapter, so begins the heart of the book, with the introduction of sandwich, the linefollowing robot. Mar 02, 2019 different optimus prime transformer robot truck toys. The book versus the movie welt am draht discussion. On another note, the movie of the same name really doesnt have much to do with the book. What are the main differences between the i, robot. The other truly great one is ray bradburys martian chronicles, although clifford d. In the book, winning a key isnt the final step of completing a challenge, because the keys only unlock a gate that leads to yet another challenge yes. The stories originally appeared in the american magazines super science stories and astounding science fiction between 1940 and 1950 and were then compiled into a book for standalone publication by gnome press in 1950, in an initial edition of 5,000 copies.
Sammy hayesrodriguez and his brobot e are making new friends every day as e works as his bedridden sister maddies school proxy. Its plot incorporates elements of little lost robot,7 some of asimovs character names and the three laws. But i read that book like 50 years ago, so the movie i, robot with will smith is actually more relevant to me today. To even tackle the difference between a movie and a book is a mortal sin. Mar 28, 2018 in the book, winning a key isnt the final step of completing a challenge, because the keys only unlock a gate that leads to yet another challenge yes, this is a bit confusing. The only relation it bears to the book is that theres a robot in it.
It was also the first feature film to use digital image processing to pixellate photography in order to simulate an androids point of view. Hes clunky, hes weird, but few robots are more iconic, influential or memorable than robbie the robot. In a certain fashion, this is typical of the work of alex proyas, the director of i, robot. Little lost robot when sonny gets lost with the remainder of the ns5 robots the evitable conflict in which the robots generalize the first law and permit some pain to protect humanitys future. For instance, the 1934 robert graves novel i, claudius tells the story from claudiuss point of view and the 1939 binder story i, robot is the robots own confession. The big technology in i, robot is robots, of course not i, which would be hilariousweve invented the first person pronoun. The character who narrates all the tales is one dr. Book vs movie i, robot replay 15th anniversary special. A detailed tour is made of the features, dials, and switches on sandwich. In 2035, a technophobic cop investigates a crime that may have been perpetrated by a robot, which leads to a larger threat to humanity. Jul 18, 2004 the new film i, robot turns scifi author isaac asimovs thoughtful short stories into a riproaring action flick while a screenplay regarded by many as a classic of the genre goes unfilmed.
You just cannot compare and contrast movies from books because it would be saying or identifying the best bunch of the two. It would have been crazy expensive, though according to wikipedia harlan ellison tried in the late 70s. Robot took the small screen by storm when it debuted in 2015. This onepage guide includes a plot summary and brief analysis of i, robot by isaac asimov. You complain alot and still on this forum, nobody and i mean nobody would care if you left, trust me it would just prove my dominance towards dc stans like you philo and abhi got tired of getting debunked over and over again on this forum by. Calvin is one of the central characters, she is played by the lovely bridget moynahan, who could hardly have been what asimov envisioned as he incorporated calvin into his numerous robotthemed works.
Book vs movie replay i, robot 15th anniversary special movie isaac asimov classic short stories vs will smith blockbuster for this. Blog 8 film analysis of i,robot chicago the year 2025, robots are manufactured to serve humans, in a world where they live simultaneously together. I watched the movie and read the book and here are my thoughts about the movie as an adaptation. In the movie the robots are good and help humans to the end. I, robot is one of the great fixup books of the early years of science fiction book publishing. Spooner, who admits to an ongoing prejudice against robots, believes the scientist. With will smith, bridget moynahan, bruce greenwood, alan tudyk. I robot, set in a possible future for mankind as our ever increasing reliance on machines develops into robots and droids. The film was nominated for hugo, nebula and saturn awards. In reality, the movie i, robot has very little to do with the aforementioned short stories other than title and common ideas. Alex proyas is probably best known for directing the crow, with brandon lee, the illfated son of bruce lee. I, robot is a classic science fiction book in the sense that it takes some technology that doesnt exist and asks, what would life be like if we did have this.
In the book, the purpose of the two simulated worlds was to gather public opinion polling data. The new film i, robot turns scifi author isaac asimovs thoughtful short stories into a riproaring action flick while a screenplay regarded by many as a. The movie does a nice job of discussing the ethical and moral challenges associated with a society where robots play such a dominant and crucial role in everyday life. Compared to the book, it portrayed a relatively similar idea, but with more excitement. The poster that said the movie covered the main points of the book has obviously not read the book. It makes them appreciate the robots zoom in used on the sunny unique robot. Aug 06, 2007 the movie on the other hand was average at best. Silver samuraikenuichio harada, big hero 6s initial field leader, first approached hiros mother for. That kind of stuff works for younger actors, but smith was roughly 34 when he shot this movie. The book isaac asimovs i, robot is not a novel in the strictest sense, but rather a series of interconnected short stories. Here is a quick list of ten key differences between humans and robots, which immediately spring to mind.
A mad doctor builds a robot in order to steal a valuable aztec treasure from a tomb guarded by a centuriesold living mummy. Robots are an integral part of societys daily life. It can be found in the anthology, robot visions, c. Im speaking of the 2004 movie starring will smith and directed by alex proyas, not the book which i liked even if it had a few flaws, as i talked about already. However, the plot of the movie is mostly original work adapted from a screenplay hardwired by jeff vintar completely unlinked to asimovs stories7 what are the main similarities differences in the movie i, robot versus asimovs. Unlike the books by asimov, the movie featured hordes of killer robots.
The book versus the movie posted 7 years ago by buckaroorobotmonster 1 reply jump to latest. I, robot is a fixup novel of science fiction short stories or essays by american writer isaac asimov. However, where this will differ is that unlike divergent which i think works as both. It was entertaining, in a summer popcorn movie kind of way. In 1971, the original 1956 robby the robot was sold to jim brucker and put on display at his movie worldcars of the stars museum, near disneyland in buena park, california, where he was often vandalized by visitors. Director alex proyas dark city, the crow helmed this scifi thriller inspired by the stories in isaac asimovs ninestory anthology of the same name. I robot movie visuals 5 film techniques long shot used where susan shows spooner the whole robot army. Its kind of funny that my big complaint about the short stories by isaac asimov that make up the book were based on characterization because that was my biggest problem with the filmed version. Young audiences who are willing to suspend disbelief and appreciate the rudimentary special effects should find much to like in the adventures of a. Now gearing up for its fourth and final season, set to premiere on october 6 with episodes, we can expect many more twists and turns to come related. I find it a little hard to describe why i like i, robot so much. Different optimus prime transformer robot truck toys. The only connection between the story little lost robot and the movie i, robot is that the missing robot was in both cases able to elude capture and otherwise. At age, hiro takachihowas was targeted by the giri, a topsecret consortium of japanese politicians and business entities that was established to recruit and train potential operatives for a japanese superteam, big hero 6.
The movie has a single main plot about a renegade robot. I, robot, the 2004 movie, has several references to the original stories by isaac asimov. I, robot seems like more conventional action oriented science fiction compared. As a result, i wound up reading the robots series, the galactic empire series, and the foundation series. Unfortunately, the trio becomes the target of the lab manager who dumped ari9 and now. The film has numerous changes to the plot and characters from the book, making the adaptation barely recognisable. With a simple story, strong rooting interest, and solid acting from both the young performers and the robot, the fact that this movie is a lowbudget hightech film doesnt matter much. Although this book is aimed at an young audience, it explores some interesting topics like human beings versus artificial intelligence, ethical use of. Aug 18, 2017 book vs movie i robot isaac asimov classic short stories vs will smith blockbuster. The 15 worst book to film adaptations of all time taste. Imy robot friend is a liveaction film about a discarded robot whos given new life by a resourceful couple of teens.
One of the most mindbending series on tv right now, with one of the most complex and multilayered characters, mr. I, robot is a short story collection published in 1950 by isaac asimov. Hit the link below to continue reading and find out the 20 best movie robots of all time. The book is a collection of short stories as told to a reporter by susan calvin. Aug 18, 2017 book vs movie i robot isaac asimov classic short stories vs will smith blockbuster for this episode of the book vs.
When the japanese government needs a team of statesanctioned superheroes at their disposal, a topsecret consortium of politicians and business entities known as the giri is formed to recruit and train potential superhuman operatives for the team, which is named big hero 6. A collection of nine stories, the book explores the relationship between robots and humans in, what was at the time of publication, the nottoodistant future. Transformers toys transformers bumblebee and optimus prime. Bro if you actually left that would make my day not even joking lol. Saying that the stepford wives is a robot movie would be considered a spoiler in some quarters, since thats actually the grand reveal. On the eve of the launch of a new, advanced order of robot technology, the scientist responsible for its development james cromwell is found dead, presumably a suicide. The crow is a cult classic, loved by goths the world over, and its cachet is only. Book vs movie replay i, robot 15th anniversary special movie isaac asimov classic short stories vs will smith blockbuster for this episode of the book vs. Now gearing up for its fourth and final season, set to premiere on october 6 with episodes, we can expect many more twists and turns to come. Deemed too costly, the movie was shelved but the script was eventually published as i, robot. What is the difference between a human and a robot. Nov 03, 2016 this book is a great starting point, and it got me hooked.
The only connection between the story little lost robot and the movie i, robot is that the missing robot was in both cases able to elude capture and otherwise act against the wishes of the humans surrounding it because it was not operating under the complete three laws of robotics. The original team consisted of silver samurai, sunfire, go go tomago. Jul 28, 2004 in reality, the movie i, robot has very little to do with the aforementioned short stories other than title and common ideas. The 15 worst book to film adaptations of all time taste of. The stories originally appeared in the american magazines super science stories and astounding science fiction between 1940 and 1950 and were then compiled into a book for standalone publication by gnome press in 1950. Eve is a robot that looks like a 12year girl, existed for about 4 years, have all the knowledge of the internet, and is still figuring out how things work in the real world like most tweens. The robots misunderstood their relation to humans and rule them by overprotecting them. Robots deliver the post, walk your dogs and collect your rubbish. The zeroth law of robotics was not a part of i,robot as it first appeared in a much later robot book called robots and empire.
While none of them are complete or true to the story, they exist. And you really cant tell the best bunch of the two no matter how conclusive your defense might be. The book versus the movie welt am draht discussion moviechat. Police detective del spooner is called in to investigate. This book is a great starting point, and it got me hooked. Bicentennial man by isaac asimov is a short story the movie is based on. I, robot is a fixup novel of science fiction short stories or essays by american writer isaac. Movie podcast the margos go back to the world of science fiction with this ep talking about the extraordinary life of isaac asimov and his most famous work out of hundreds of books, essays, letters, etc. The robot continues to surprise his new friends with his powers and his accessible personality. Book vs movie i robot isaac asimov classic short stories vs will smith blockbuster. It is certainly not something that happens in the book after which the movie is. In the middle level reality, there is an army of people whose job it is to invade peoples privacy and ask them questions about clothing styles and such.
1489 60 859 680 557 499 55 996 1090 1590 778 321 974 257 115 295 43 555 155 264 333 632 804 79 1293 223 891 589 971 665 71 242 1521 545 186 474 583 4 824 378 324 925 877 996 1191 1078 669 1241 897